A Tourism Management Plan for Harris

Client

North, West Harris Trusts, Outer Hebrides Tourist Board

Services

Visitor Management Planning

Harris Visitor Management Plan: Balancing Tourism Growth with Sustainability

In February 2021, I was commissioned to develop the Harris Visitor Management Plan, a project funded by NatureScot and commissioned by the North Harris Trust, West Harris Trust, and Outer Hebrides Tourism. With a tight deadline of March 31, 2021, the goal was clear: address the challenges caused by increasing visitor numbers in Harris, especially in popular areas like Hushinish, Luskentyre, and Norton, and develop sustainable solutions to benefit the local community and environment.

Background: Rising Tourism Pressure

Pre-COVID, Harris experienced significant growth in tourism numbers, creating immense pressure on the island’s limited infrastructure. This was exacerbated during the post-COVID travel boom, as domestic visitors flocked to Harris when overseas travel was restricted.

Key concerns raised by the North and West Harris Trusts and the Outer Hebrides Tourism included:

  • Strain on local infrastructure in key hotspots.
  • Parking issues and irresponsible behaviour by visitors.
  • Impacts on the local community, crofters, and the island’s pristine environment.

The project’s objective was to identify the key visitor management challenges and provide actionable solutions that balanced tourism growth with community and environmental sustainability.

My deep understanding of Harris—built through annual visits since 2012—and my tourism and marketing expertise uniquely qualified me to take on this project.

Research and Methodology

The research phase was comprehensive and collaborative, involving:

  1. Online surveys  to gather insights from visitors and locals.
  2. Zoom Meetings with key stakeholders to understand concerns and potential solutions.
  3. Case Studies of areas with similar visitor management challenges, such as the Lake District.
  4. Face-to-face discussions with organisations like the council, Caledonian MacBrayne, and VisitScotland.
  5. Interviews with Other Islands, including VisitArran and Skye Connect, to learn from their experiences.

Harris – Andrew Drane

Key Issues Identified

The research uncovered several pressing issues impacting Harris, including:

  • Lack of visitor knowledge about driving on single-track roads.
  • Parking problems at scenic hotspots and laybys.
  • Irresponsible behaviour by motorhome users, such as overnight parking and waste disposal.
  • Challenges with wild camping and environmental impacts.
  • Littering, toilet waste, and general disrespect for the local environment.
  • Limited signage to inform visitors about parking availability or challenging road conditions.

Key Recommendations

The Harris Visitor Management Plan proposed several strategic solutions, including:

  1. Proactive Communication: Set expectations with the local community, stakeholders, and visitors.
  2. Visitor Contributions: Introduce parking fees for toilet facilities to support infrastructure.
  3. Seasonal Wardens: Deploy wardens during peak tourist seasons to monitor and manage visitor behaviour.
  4. Enforcement Fines: Implement penalties for irresponsible actions like littering or unauthorised parking.
  5. Seasonal Extension: Encourage tourism beyond peak months to distribute visitor numbers more evenly.

Results and Impact

The Harris Visitor Management Plan has been praised as an exemplar of sustainable tourism management, with several key initiatives successfully implemented:

  1. “Harris Is a Unique Place” Campaign: A responsible tourism campaign launched by Outer Hebrides Tourism to educate visitors on preserving Harris’s natural beauty. This campaign has since been extended across the Outer Hebrides and promoted by Caledonian MacBrayne on their website, app, and ferry services.
  2. Improved Signage: In 2023, new signage was introduced to educate visitors on how to be responsible tourists and avoid environmental harm.
  3. Seasonal Wardens: Since 2021, wardens have been deployed during peak seasons to monitor and manage visitor behaviour.
  4. Parking Management at Hushinish Gateway: The North Harris Trust introduced parking fees and prohibited parking on the machair, ensuring crofters can access their homes while generating income for the Trust. A dedicated parking area for motorhomes has also been created, offering scenic views while reducing environmental impacts.

Conclusion: A Model for Sustainable Visitor Management

The Harris Visitor Management Plan has proven to be a successful blueprint for balancing tourism growth with preserving Harris’s unique environment and community well-being. By addressing key challenges like infrastructure strain, irresponsible visitor behaviour, and the need for proactive communication, the plan has ensured that Harris remains a pristine and welcoming destination for years.

This project highlights the importance of sustainable tourism strategies, and its outcomes have inspired similar initiatives across the Outer Hebrides and beyond.

 

Harris -Andrew Drane

Related Case Studies