Before you build: how architects and tourism businesses can design for the guests they want to attract

If you showed me plans for four new holiday lets, the first thing I’d ask is: who do you see booking them on a wet weekend in November?
The answer might be couples escaping for a few days with the dog. It might be a family gathering for a birthday. Both can be good markets, but they need quite different buildings. And if your figures rely on November bookings, it’s worth finding out how much demand there really is before you build.
There’s a moment in every development when the drawings make the idea feel real. You can picture the view from the windows and imagine guests arriving. I love that stage too. It’s also the right time to ask what guests will pay, how often they’ll book and what it will cost to run. A tourism feasibility study gives you and your architect evidence on who’s likely to book, what they’ll pay and how that might shape what you build.
That’s where I come in. I’ve worked in Scottish tourism for over 30 years, and today I help rural tourism businesses, property owners and community organisations across Scotland. A big part of what I do is helping people make these decisions before they commit to building.
Who will stay, and what will they need?
I spend a lot of time looking at how people choose and book self-catering accommodation, and what matters to guests is often very practical. If you’re hoping to attract couples with dogs, where will they dry a wet dog after a walk? Is the garden enclosed? As a wild swimmer myself, I know how much a good place to dry off and warm up matters. If you’re aiming for families or groups, are there enough bathrooms, and is there space for everyone to sit comfortably together?
Those details can shape everything from the layout to the number and size of the units. Four smaller properties might suit one market. Two larger ones might give you a stronger offer for another. I’d want to look at the evidence for both before settling on the mix.
I also look well beyond the immediate area. Owners often see the nearest holiday lets as their main competition. But a couple choosing a long weekend might have a cottage in the Scottish Borders, a converted farm building in Dumfries and Galloway and a lodge in Perthshire open in three tabs. I want to understand why they’d pick yours, at your price, for the dates they want.
What would a realistic first year look like?
I start with what comparable properties charge at different times of year and what guests get for that price. Then I look at when your property is likely to sell, how long guests might stay and how quickly bookings could build after opening.
A good rate in July tells you something about July. It tells you very little about a Tuesday in November, and annual occupancy can hide that difference, especially if the business needs shoulder-season bookings to cover costs. A new property also needs time to build awareness and gather reviews, so I give the first year its own assumptions.
I then test what happens if the opening slips and you miss part of your first summer, or if winter bookings take longer to build. If that leaves a cash shortfall in year one, you need to know how much it is and how you’ll cover it while you still have choices about the scale and timing of the development.
Who will get the bookings and look after the guests?
I bring this into the business plan early because it affects what you earn from each stay and how much of the work falls to you.
Larger online travel platforms can put your property in front of a very wide audience. A specialist letting agency can bring an established audience and help with bookings and guest enquiries. If you want Scottish expertise, it’s also worth looking at smaller agencies such as Unique Cottages, which is based in the Scottish Borders. Taking bookings through your own website gives you more control over the relationship with guests, but it means budgeting for a booking system, marketing and the time it takes to handle enquiries. You need to consider if you have time and the expertise for this.
I compare what you keep from a booking under each option and who does the work. Someone still must organise changeovers, answer the phone when the heating goes off and replace the sofa when it wears out. I put a cost against the owner’s time alongside cleaning, utilities, maintenance, insurance and replacements. In Scotland, I also check the licensing, planning and visitor levy position for the site, so any costs or implications for opening are reflected in the plan.
When the research changes the brief
One of the most valuable outcomes of a feasibility study can be a change to the drawings. You might decide to build fewer units and give each one more privacy, redesign a layout for the guests most likely to book, or open in phases. On a farm, estate or heritage site, the research might point to a different visitor experience altogether. It can also give you a sound basis for going ahead with the plans you already have.
This is where working alongside an architect really helps. I bring evidence on guests, pricing, demand and likely income into the conversation while there’s still room to change the design. The architect can then advise on what those changes would mean for the site and the building. You get both views when you decide what to invest in.
How I can help
I carry out tourism feasibility studies and write business plans for property owners, farms, estates, trusts and community organisations across Scotland. I can look at the whole project or help with one specific decision, such as which accommodation mix to pursue, what rates and occupancy to use in the business plan, or how to bring the property to market.
If you’re developing a project, or advising a client who is, I’d love to hear about it. Get in touch and tell me what you’re considering and which decision you need to make next.
